Well-Being Georgia

in partnership with

Augusta University of Health

COVID-19 Impact on Georgia Latest Articles

April 23, 2021

Are Your Remote Workdays Exhausting? Here’s Why—and What to Do About It

Are Your Remote Workdays Exhausting? Here’s Why—and What to Do About It

As huge swaths of society moved from real life to video during the first weeks of the COVID-19 lockdown that began in March 2020, the use of video platforms skyrocketed. Hundreds of millions of people began signing onto services like Zoom, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams each day.

And despite the now-familiar hiccups—bandwidth deficits, login snafus and abruptly ending meetings—video conferences seemed like one silver lining for workers amid the disruption and pain caused by the pandemic. After all, what a timesaver it’s been to click into daily meetings without having to shower, get dressed or commute to the office.

But a year of Zooming has taken a toll on home office workers, many of whom began asking themselves: If video meetings require such a light lift physically, why do I feel so wiped out after a virtual workday?

“I think when many people very quickly transitioned to working from home and social distancing, we tried to recreate the experiences we have in person,” says Andrew Bennett, PhD, a researcher in employee well-being at Old Dominion University in Norfolk, Virginia and co-author of a 2021 study on videoconference fatigue. “Maybe we scheduled too many videoconferences instead of using email or the phone and, therefore, many people started feeling and recognizing this videoconference fatigue.”

With the steady climb in vaccinations and more states reopening, many workers around the United States are responding to home office strain by making plans to return in person.

According to a March 2021 snapshot survey from Sharecare’s Community Well-Being Index of 1,011 respondents in the U.S., 47 percent said they’d prefer to return to in-person work when restrictions are lifted, compared to 40 percent who’d choose to remain remote. (An additional 13 percent anticipate working remotely for health reasons.)

Those who opt to continue working remotely will have to contend with what’s been dubbed “Zoom fatigue,” a phenomenon that’s hit women especially hard. In fact, women reported nearly 14 percent higher levels of Zoom fatigue, compared to men, according to findings published in April 2021 by researchers at Stanford University. 

Why are Zoom meetings so draining?
Think of a typical in-person meeting. Picture the conference room. When someone is presenting, what are you looking at? Most likely, your gaze wanders from the speaker to other participants, to the window, the floor, your notes.

Now picture your last video conference. You probably spent most of the time staring into the speaker’s face, monitoring their tone, pitch and a variety of nonverbal cues. That attention requires subtle but substantial mental effort. Meanwhile, you’re obliged to perform the same way when you’re speaking: nodding, smiling and looking into the camera to make eye contact.

Sending and receiving these signals in tight focus can be draining, physically and mentally, says Jeremy Bailenson, PhD, founding director of Stanford University’s Virtual Human Interaction Lab and author of a February 2021 study in Technology, Mind, and Behavior on “nonverbal overload.” (He is also co-author of the April 2021 paper, which has not yet been peer-reviewed, that looks at gender differences in Zoom fatigue.) 

Aside from the cognitive strain of responding to and communicating with nonverbal cues, Bailenson identifies several aspects of Zooming that can zap your energy.

Intense close-ups: According to Bailenson’s research, you’d need to stand about 19 inches away from the person you’re speaking to in order to approximate the closeness simulated by a Zoom call. For context, intimate space is typically defined as falling within the range of 18 inches of another person.

This means that when you’re on your team Zoom, you’re engaging with your coworkers at a distance usually reserved for loved ones.

And it’s not just that everyone feels closer to you. They’re also staring at you, which research shows can cause physiological arousal. Being in a prolonged state of arousal can trick your brain into thinking you’re in a situation that could lead to conflict—rather than a friendly morning check-in. Bailenson and his colleagues found that women reported higher levels of this sensation in their experiences with Zoom calls than men did. 

Mirror effect: Another thing you’re likely not doing during an in-person meeting: staring at yourself. Imagine giving a presentation while someone holds a mirror in front of you. Not only would it be hard to concentrate, but you’d be spending mental energy toggling between listening and evaluating how you’re doing and how you look.

In this way, the self-view feature of many videoconference apps adds another layer of stress, which Bailenson and his colleagues describe as a form of “mirror anxiety.” Women may be more likely than men to experience added stress from this mirror effect, according to Bailenson’s research.

Locked in place: Video meetings can also have the effect of reducing your mobility. During an in-person meeting, you may get up to grab some water or draw on the whiteboard. On a phone call at home, you may pace your apartment or tend to chores like watering the plants.

While it’s acceptable to do these things on a call where people can’t see you, it’s less so on a video call because your absence from the frame is conspicuous, which can contribute to a feeling of being trapped in the virtual meeting space. Moving around throughout your day can help boost your energy; staying chained to your chair during a Zoom can be a drain. Bailenson’s research found higher levels of this feeling among women than among men.

How to reduce Zoom fatigue
Fortunately, there are some simple research-backed modifications you can make to your setup that may ease Zoom fatigue.

Hide yourself. For starters, Bailenson recommends turning off your self-view. Others will be able to see you, but you won’t be able to see yourself, which will stop you from fixating on your appearance. To do this on Zoom, right-click your self-video and select "Hide Myself."

“It will take a few days to get used to it, but you will feel better over time,” Bailenson says.

Keep things in perspective. The size of your video window also matters. Because closeups of faces can make it feel as though your personal space is being invaded, Bailenson recommends minimizing the video window so that it only takes up one-third of your computer screen.

Foster team spirit. According to Bennett and his colleagues, the least draining meetings were the ones with the greatest sense of “group belongingness.” So, when feasible, allow time at the top of the meeting for participants to chat and get to know one another.

“Try to feel part of the group on the video meeting and help others feel that as well,” Bennett recommends. “The more connected people felt to others in that group, the less fatigued they felt afterwards.”

Time it right. If you’re the one setting up meetings, try scheduling video calls for earlier in the afternoon. “We know that people are more fatigued at the end of their work shift,” Bennett says. “And it seems that people are even more fatigued when they have a videoconference in the later part of the workday.”

The Old Dominion researchers found 1:30 p.m., or just after lunch, to be an ideal time. Lunch breaks can help relieve fatigue, but they can also cause your attention to dip when you return to work. So, if you’re feeling a boost of energy after lunch, hopping on Zoom may not feel so draining. Meanwhile, the energy you need to muster to make it through a video call may help smooth over any post-lunch productivity dips you’d otherwise feel. 

Step out of the spotlight (when you can). All in all, Bailenson recommends being mindful of how frequently you schedule video calls or how often you ask your employees to keep their video on. If you're the boss, remember that your employees don't have the same luxury you do to choose the amount of time they spend on camera.

“As a manager, I didn't realize this until my colleagues made it clear to me,” he says.

If you’re feeling tapped out, ask your manager if you can turn off your video occasionally or switch the meeting to a phone call to preserve your resources for the next Zoom.

Medically reviewed in March 2021. Updated in April 2021.

Sources:

Bailenson, J. N. “Nonverbal overload: A theoretical argument for the causes of Zoom fatigue.” Technology, Mind, and Behavior. 2021;2(1).
Bennett, Andrew A.; Campion, Emily D.; Keeler, Kathleen R.; and Keener, Sheila K. “Videoconference Fatigue Exploring Changes in Fatigue after Videoconference Meetings during COVID-19.” Management Faculty Publications. 2021;38.
Jarick, M., & Bencic, R. “Eye contact is a two-way street: Arousal is elicited by the sending and receiving of eye gaze information.” Frontiers in psychology. 2019;10, 1262.
Vikas, Mehta. “The new proxemics: COVID-19, social distancing, and sociable space, Journal of Urban Design.” 2020;25:6, 669-674.
Fauville, Géraldine; Luo, Mufan; Queiroz, Anna C. M.; Bailenson, J. N.; Hancock, Jeffrey. “Nonverbal Mechanisms Predict Zoom Fatigue and Explain Why Women Experience Higher Levels than Men.” SSRN. April 5, 2021. 

 

Categories:

Well-Being